WHO Poll
Q: 2023/24 Hopes & aspirations for this season
a. As Champions of Europe there's no reason we shouldn't be pushing for a top 7 spot & a run in the Cups
24%
  
b. Last season was a trophy winning one and there's only one way to go after that, I expect a dull mid table bore fest of a season
17%
  
c. Buy some f***ing players or we're in a battle to stay up & that's as good as it gets
18%
  
d. Moyes out
37%
  
e. New season you say, woohoo time to get the new kit and wear it it to the pub for all the big games, the wags down there call me Mr West Ham
3%
  



Nasty_Nick 3:30 Thu Apr 30
Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
http://hereisthecity.com/en-gb/2015/04/29/mark-noble-could-be-the-perfect-number-10-for-west-ham-with-down/

Earlier this season, things were going rather well for West Ham, with Noble playing in a diamond midfield alongside Alex Song, Cheikhou Kouyate and Stewart Downing.

Noble was the willing runner in that system, harrying opponents on the ball, and creating the off chance. However, main playmaking duties were left to Song - in the deep-lying midfield role - and Downing, who was the number 10.

This led the East London club up the Premier League table, and won head coach Sam Allardyce some deserved plaudits.

However, injuries and a loss in form to Downing and Song have resulted in just two victories for the Hammers in 2015, and a top 10 placing looks out of the question. Obviously these issues are not down to any specific person, although the continual inclusion of Kevin Nolan raises a few eyebrows.

Playing as the number 10 following Downing’s loss in form, Nolan looks off the pace when asked to perform weekly in the top flight. A great servant of the club, his time is surely up, and it begs the question of who can take his place as the teams main playmaker.

Nolan is past his best, Downing himself is ageing, and it creates a huge tactical issue for Allardyce.

However, Noble has all the abilities to play in that advanced role, and it arguably suits him, and the team, better than his current position.


Noble plays the second most key passes in the entire Hammers squad - 1.4 per game to Downing’s 2.4 - whilst possessing a higher pass accuracy than the former Liverpool man. He also, surprisingly, completes more dribbles than Downing and draws more fouls than the winger.

His attacking play is impressive, especially considering his usual deep-lying role restricts his effect in the final third, and just imagine how effective he would be if let loose from his defensive responsibilities.

Speaking of these responsibilities, Noble is also a far better option in the number 10 role than Downing when it comes to pressing from the front and the need to win the ball back early.

The 27-year-old completes 2.5 tackles per game and two interceptions per game, far better than Downing, and even toning these down to increase his attacking efficiency would make him a far better all-round number 10 than Downing.

Downing and Nolan have enjoyed successful careers as playmakers, but it looks as if their time at the top of their game is coming to an end. Rather than persevering with the ageing duo, Allardyce should look towards Noble as his main creative outlet, with the tireless midfielder potentially a fix for a key tactical issue in the Hammers current set-up.

Replies - In Chronological Order (Show Newest Messages First)

goose 3:32 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?

nope.

On The Ball 3:32 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Does it matter? It's not going to happen!

Spandex Sidney 3:33 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Could he do it from his armchair in the middle of the pitch?

Nasty_Nick 3:35 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
OTB - this is a West Ham forum to discuss things West Ham?

JGW1 3:38 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
hahahahah

comical if true. Noble patently lacks exactly what he's apparently being credited for here. He has poor pass selection and typically takes far too long to make the pass by which time he's telegraphed what he's going to do.

Could he be an effective playmaker? Absolutely NO!

BTW, I like the guy and think his real asset is his prodigous energy level and think he would be far more effective with an outstanding creative midfielder alongside him. He's just not a very talented footballer himself.

monto 3:39 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Got more chance of being a playwright.

Alex V 3:41 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
>>> Downing and Nolan have enjoyed successful careers as playmakers

Have they?

Hermit Road 3:42 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Only if he joins an amateur dramatic company.

OneAll 3:45 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
He could definitely play the advanced playmaker role, his to slow for anything else

One McAvennieeeeee 3:45 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Superb Footballer. Could play anywhere.

cornish 3:46 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
No!

Lee Trundle 3:46 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
I'd like West Ham's PLAYMAKER to occasionally score a few goals here and there.

Unfortunately, I don't think Noble has that in him. He's better off playing where he is. It's where he's picked up the Hammer of the Year award 2 out of the past 3 seasons.

Mr Kenzo 3:51 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Bin the cunt

under the thumb 3:52 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Fucking ding ding is it April the fucking 1st!!!!!!
I've read some shit articles in my life but that takes the biscuit.
Total utter bollocks.

Eddie B 3:52 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Too........








....... slow.

Alex V 3:54 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
You can be a playmaker from almost any midfield role - it's more a measure of what you achieve, than where or how you're played. Noble has 10 assists in 3 prem seasons, including all the set pieces he's taken - not really any sort of record for a playmaker, is it?

I do think he could play at the front of the diamond and do okay, but I don't think the diamond is an effective strategy anyway, so it's a pointless debate.

mentor 3:54 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
In the Championship, yes.

Terrywait 3:55 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Maybe then he'd try a shot from outside the box, and not just one of his gash free kicks

Swiss. 3:56 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
Passing sideways and backwards doesn't usually result in goals. So no.

Swiss. 3:57 Thu Apr 30
Re: Could Noble be an option as playmaker?
cue another 500 post debate on pro-Nobles v anti-Nobles

Page 1 - Next




Copyright 2006 WHO.NET | Powered by: